Paranormal Cozy Mysteries
Paranormal cozy mysteries are among the most popular cozy mystery subgenres. These mysteries feature amateur sleuths who use a supernatural ability to solve whodunits in the human or magical world. Whether it’s a witch, a talking cat, a ghost, or a psychic twist, paranormal elements add a bit of mischief and magic to every cozy mystery. All of the paranormal cozy mysteries on this page have a supernatural element and good reader reviews.
Witchy cozy mysteries feature an amateur sleuth who uses supernatural abilities to solve mysteries. Here are 12 Must-Read Witch Cozy Mysteries.
Essence of Foul Play is a great start to a new cozy mystery series with a unique hook, a likeable sleuth, and just a touch of fairy magic.
Eat, Pray, Hex is one of those books that looks and sounds good from the start and gets better and better as you read. This witchy cozy mystery has some genuine laugh-out-loud moments thanks to the author’s wickedly good sense of humor.
A Cattitude Christmas perfectly captures the magic of the season. This witchy cozy mystery is a feel-good tale with devilishly good humor, holiday warmth, and a group of characters that will make you smile and tug at your heart.
Written by a true master of the genre, Murder at Blackwood Inn boasts an atmospheric seaside setting and a wealth of entertaining elements—from a ghostwriting sleuth and a haunted inn to eccentric aunts who dabble in crystals and poison gardens.
Six Tails Past Midnight is a whimsical and imaginative cat-centric mystery filled with charm, puns, and catnip-laced wit. This installment in the No. 2 Feline Detective Agency series will have fans of the Feline Detective Agency purring in satisfaction.
Ms. Renfield and the Inheritance Trap is a wickedly fun paranormal rom-com with sharp banter, clever twists, and a vampire boss who’s equal parts menace and allure. It's a wildly entertaining read that sinks its teeth in and doesn't let go.
Ill-Fated Fortune is well-written, sweet, and suspenseful with the perfect mix of mystery and magical realism. It features delightful streaks of humor, delectable food descriptions, and a mystery that keeps you guessing until the final reveal.
Bewitch and Bloom is a spellbinding women’s fiction novel with witchy charm, female friendship, and enough excitement to demonstrate that mystery and magic really do begin in midlife.
Candy, Cauldrons, and a Corpse is a sweet and spooky mystery full of small-town charm. The well-written and fast-paced story is enchanting and keeps you spellbound from the first page to the last.
Witch and Tell is a perfectly brewed mystery with a dash of witchy wonder. Bestselling author Angela M. Sanders crafts a tale so cozy and clever, you’ll wish you could join sleuth Josie Way for a cup of tea and a little spellcasting of your own.
Pride and Prejudice and Potions: Lizzy's Story is the perfect blend of cozy fantasy, mystery, and no-spice sweet romance. The hat tips to the original Pride and Prejudice story are plentiful and a joy to read.
A Brew for Chaos is an enchanting mix of cozy mystery, magical intrigue, and small-town charm. The charming backdrop and the cozy fall vibes contrast very well with the chilling mystery and complex plot.
Shofar, So Good is a delightfully refreshing cozy mystery that weaves together family drama, faith, suspense, and holiday tension. It’s a satisfying blend of mystery, emotional stakes, and community.
Whiskers and Ciphers is an engaging read with just the right mix of suspense and charm. The brilliant chemistry between the amateur sleuth and her talking cat adds heart and humor to this delightful paranormal cozy mystery.
Hexes and Hush Money is a magical mix of supernatural charm, mystery, and feline mischief in a cozy seaside setting. It's a purr-fect read for fans of cat-centric cozy mysteries and books with witchy vibes.
Linzer Cookie Murder is a charming holiday confection of a mystery with a big-hearted sleuth, a festive theme, and a pinch of mistletoe magic. The coziness of this sweet mystery will have you reaching for a cup of cocoa and a plate of jam-filled cookies.
Peppermint Cookie Murder is a whimsical Christmas whodunit that is part fairy tale, part murder mystery, and part coming-of-age story. It has a sweet heroine, a furry sidekick, an enchanting adventure, and a sweet selection of holiday recipes.
Hammers and Homicide has all of the elements that cozy mystery readers love best: a charming small town, a relatable sleuth, lighthearted moments, a puzzling mystery, a great community, and heartfelt relationships.
Axe Me No Questions is a good mystery with small-town suspense, super cozy vibes, and a touch of paranormal. The amateur sleuth is a lively senior who is sharp, funny, and relatable. She teams up with her daughter to solve mysteries.
A Zappy Little Christmas is a sparkling holiday mystery full of small-town warmth, witty banter, and just the right dose of ghostly mischief. This cozy Christmas caper will make you smile and gasp and everything in between.
Flashes of a Dying Hour expertly combines suspense, history, female friendship, humor, and just a hint of the supernatural. It’s a compelling, multi-dimensional cozy mystery with a unique twist.
Wand, Waffles, and Whispers is an engaging, heartwarming read that fans of paranormal cozies and culinary mysteries will devour. Readers should prepare to be enchanted by Skylar, the talking cat who steals every scene with sass and sharp insight.
Puzzles and Premieres is a wonderfully whimsical paranormal cozy mystery that blends magic, puzzles, and movie‑festival glamour into a uniquely charming tale. It is an entertaining ride from the first frame to the final scene.
Haunting and Homicide is a fun paranormal mystery with an original hook and a great setting. Well-drawn characters, including the sleuth, a ghost buddy, and an adorable beagle pup, make the book extra charming.
A Spirited Blend is the final book in the Crystals & CuriosiTEAS Mystery trilogy. This paranormal cozy mystery, set in a cute, kooky setting, is a fun, thematic read for the Spooky Season.
This page contains affiliate links. Cozy Crime Reads may earn a commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.